Key takeaways
In the early days, nothing has a higher ROI than your co-founder selection.
A 50/50 equity split does not create a 50/50 partnership.
The best founder agreements never have to be enforced.
Introduction
Three choices shape much of our lives: what we do, where we do it, and who we do it with.
Building a company is no different.
Yet founders often pour their time and energy into deciding what to build and figuring out how to make it work. Where to build it and who to build it with rarely gets the same attention.
I believe this to be a mistake. In the early days, nothing matters more than choosing the right co-founder (or avoiding the wrong one).
Why do founders spend less time on this? I think part of the reason is what makes entrepreneurs tick. Commonly, they are energetic, optimistic (sometimes somewhat delusional) about the future and move fast. Those qualities can become liabilities when choosing a co-founder – which usually takes much more time and effort than founders would like. Same as dating.
After all, why shouldn’t you “just” co-found with someone who likes your idea, brings skills you lack and with whom you seem to get along well? Aren’t you more likely to succeed with somebody who shares the burden than on your own? Perhaps. But not if it is the wrong person.
This is the pattern: a founder with a business background finds a promising CTO, or vice versa, and the excitement of getting started quietly shifts the conversation from “Should we do this together?” to “How do we build this business?”
The second question is much more fun to explore, so the first often goes unanswered. That proves costly down the road. Shared enthusiasm may get a relationship off the ground, but it tells you little about whether it can weather disappointment, financial strain, strategic disagreements, and changing circumstances. All of which you’ll face along the startup journey.
In other words, assuming that the first potential co-founder you meet is the right partner for the entire lifecycle of your company is a little like assuming your first date will lead to a lasting marriage. It’s the exception. Not the rule.
While entire books have been written on the subject, this guide offers practical advice on choosing a co-founder and what break-up terms to put in place before getting started.
Choosing the right co-founder
Objective: Gather evidence about the potential partnership and test your assumptions.
There are many ways to assess a partnership. In my experience, self-reflection and honest conversations with your potential co-founder are a good starting point. Working together on a preliminary basis then gives you a chance to put your assumptions to the test.
My most important advice is simple: Take your time. Give this decision as much thought as you would deciding whom to marry. Over the next 5-10 years, you’ll likely spend as much time with them as with your (hypothetical) spouse.
For most founders, this means moving more slowly than they’d like. There’s no shortcut to getting to know someone.
What if you don’t have time?
Then you need to make time. Even if you’ve known your potential co-founder for years as a friend, business acquaintance, or family member, running a startup together is very different from spending weekends together, getting along at family gatherings, or working alongside each other at a big corporation.
Here’s how I recommend getting started.
Look inward
- Can I see myself working closely with this person for the next five to ten years?
- Do I respect this person intellectually and personally? If so, why?
- What doubts am I brushing aside because I want this startup to work?
- Would I still choose this partnership if I felt comfortable continuing alone?
- Would I still choose this partnership if I had other potential co-founders?
Look outward
- How have I seen them respond to criticism, setbacks and disagreement?
- Have I seen them persist through difficult work outside their comfort zone?
- Do they understand and appreciate what I contribute, and do I understand their contribution?
- Have I been able to confirm their skillset and character traits?
Examine shared experience
- How long have we known each other, and how much time have we actually spent together?
- Have we delivered something together under pressure?
- Where do our strengths complement each other?
Compare expectations
- Why does each of us want to build this company?
- What are our personal goals, and what do we want to achieve together?
- What do we expect from each other?
- What is each of us willing and able to commit (e.g. time, money and other resources)?
- What concerns have we not yet said out loud?
Red flags
If any of the following resonates, take it seriously.
- Every time you raise salaries, time commitments or what happens if someone leaves, the answer is: “Let’s sort that out once we get going / receive funding / have an MVP.”
- They miss agreed deadlines, and you keep telling yourself things will be different once you start properly.
- You ask how much time they can commit, and they respond: “If you trusted me, you wouldn’t need to ask.”
- When someone asks why you will work well together, your answer isn’t based on shared work experience.
Final remark
Deciding not to co-found, or to wait for more evidence, is a valid outcome. The goal is to find out whether the partnership works long-term (5+ years), not to talk yourselves into believing it might survive the first couple of months. Figure out how to verify your assumptions and don’t take a final decision until you achieve a level of certainty about the success chances of the partnership that makes you confident.
What to agree in writing (the “break-up terms”)
Objective: Agree how you will work together and how you would handle a potential break-up.
No matter how long you have known each other or how carefully you have checked that your values, motivations and objectives align and your skills complement each other, you still need a co-founder agreement that addresses a potential break-up. Here are three reasons why:
The agreement serves as a checklist.
It ensures that you align on critical issues.
The agreement serves as confirmation that what was communicated between the co-founders is now in writing.
(Yes, there’s a difference. Compare it to the difference between a potential customer saying that they would buy from you vs. them actually paying you.)
The agreement serves as a fallback.
Even if communication with a departing co-founder breaks down completely, the agreement should allow the company and remaining founders to move forward with certainty on the departure terms and process.
What must be included in the agreement?
The central questions that must be addressed are ownership (equity and vesting) and control: who owns what, and who can make which decisions? The list below also includes other important topics that often lead to discussions among the founders.
Your agreement checklist
0 of 11 points agreed
Tick each point once you have agreed it with your co-founders. Your ticks are saved in this browser only.
Roles, responsibilities, time commitment and compensation
General note
Allocate responsibilities even when everyone wears several hats. Record expected outcomes, time commitments and financial needs, then review them regularly as the business develops.
Equity and vesting
Note on equity splits
The case for an equal split is straightforward. At the start, it’s hard to predict how much value each co-founder will create over the next five years. If everyone is making a comparable commitment and taking comparable risks, an equal split can be a fair starting point.
The case for an unequal split is that some differences are already visible. One founder may be going full-time while another plans to stay part-time. One may be taking on broader responsibilities or more financial risk. Even when everyone starts with the same intentions, their contributions can diverge as the business develops. That’s a normal part of building a company together, and it’s worth discussing when you decide how to share ownership. A weighted exercise like EWOR’s can help you see which contributions each of you values and where your assumptions differ. In short it consists of two parts:
- a) how do you evaluate and weigh each co-founder’s contribution to (i) the idea, (ii) their domain expertise, (iii) their commitment & risk and (iv) share of the responsibilities; and
- b) does this evaluation justify an unequal equity split?
I’ve seen both approaches work. In my experience, the most exceptional outcomes have tended to come from teams with unequal splits. I treat that as a personal observation and not as a general rule.
Whatever split you choose, make sure each founder can explain why it feels fair and what assumptions it rests on. Set a date to revisit those assumptions, say after six or twelve months, and agree which changes in role, commitment or risk would prompt a discussion about adjusting ownership. The review gives you a chance to compare what you expected with what actually happened.
Note on vesting terms
Founder vesting helps keep ownership aligned with continued contribution. If a founder leaves, the agreement should give the company or another eligible buyer the right to repurchase some or all of their shares. A large stake held by a former founder will make it harder to offer meaningful equity to future team members who will build the business and can complicate fundraising. At the same time, a founder who leaves after eighteen months may have made a substantial contribution. The terms should account for both interests. Here’s how to approach this:
Nothing vests in the first year, 25% vests at the first anniversary and the rest typically vests monthly over the next three years.
- Agree the schedule.
- Four years with a one-year cliff is often referred to as market standard. Under that schedule, nothing vests in the first year, 25% vests at the first anniversary, and the rest typically vests monthly over the next three years. I’ve also seen seven-year schedules with a two-year cliff and three-year schedules with no cliff.
- Decide what can be repurchased.
- Set separate rules for vested (“earned”) and unvested (“unearned”) shares. If vested shares can also be repurchased, say when, how many and at what price. This often becomes contentious because of the misalignment between company and founder interests. One possible compromise for a departure before the end of vesting is to let the founder only keep their vested shares up to an agreed cap (e.g. 5% of the issued share capital).
- Set a price the buyer can pay.
- A clearly defined pricing method, such as book value or an agreed revenue multiple where appropriate, is preferable to a “fair market value” or “funding round valuation” reference. Specify the calculation, the valuation date and how disagreements will be resolved. I’ve seen vague pricing provisions lead to months of negotiation and tens of thousands in legal fees, with the founders still unsure what the shares would cost or whether the buyer could afford them.
- Define what makes someone a good or bad leaver.
- The labels matter because they can change which shares a founder keeps and what they receive for shares that are repurchased. Spell out how the terms apply to a mutually agreed departure, a founder-initiated departure and a company-initiated departure. In reality, there are more potential scenarios and they usually overlap to a certain extent. A founder should however be able to read the agreement and understand what they would keep and what they would be paid in each scenario.
Control
Note on decision-making
I recommend giving each founder the final say within their area of responsibility. For example, the CTO might decide how to build the product, while the CEO decides how to sell it. When a decision affects both areas, such as promising a customer a feature by a certain date, agree how the founders will make that decision together.
Decisions about the company’s overall direction are harder. I favor agreeing in advance that one founder has the final say on specified strategic questions if the founders have heard each other out and still disagree. Some decisions have to be made in time to matter. When either option is workable, staying stuck can cost the company more than choosing one and moving ahead.
Be clear about which decisions this rule covers and which still require joint agreement or formal approval. A tie-break rule works best when everyone knows when it applies and who gets to use it.
Intellectual property (“asset”) ownership
Comment on IP ownership
Start by identifying the IP and business assets that make (or will make) the business valuable, such as its software, designs or proprietary technology. Find out who owns it and, where possible, transfer ownership of the core IP to the company.
Final remarks
Revisit the agreement as you learn.
In the early days, I suggest reviewing the main terms every three to six months. Once you’ve spent time building the business together, you’ll know more about what each founder can commit, how responsibilities are shared and where disagreements tend to arise. Compare what you assumed at the start with what has happened in practice. If those assumptions have changed, discuss whether the terms still work for everyone.
Agree on the difficult things while you’re getting along.
I think of a co-founder agreement like accident insurance. You hope you’ll never have to rely on its departure provisions. If the relationship breaks down, you’ll be glad you agreed in advance who can make decisions, what happens to the departing founder’s shares and how the business can keep operating.
Lengthy agreements don’t guarantee workable outcomes.
I regularly handle founder disputes involving shareholders’ agreements that run to more than 20 pages and still leave basic questions unanswered. Whatever the length of the agreement or who drafted it, judge it by whether it gives you answers to the questions outlined above.
Turn the checklist into a signed agreement
Fehr Legal drafts co-founder agreements that answer these questions in writing: roles and pay, equity and vesting, control, and IP.
The fee depends on custom control and veto rights, founder vesting and leaver terms, IP to transfer from founders, and how much negotiation between founders is needed.
A co-founder already leaving? We also advise on founder departures, quoted by scope.
Managing a founder departure
Objective: Reach an agreement that enables the company to thrive.
A separation can be the right outcome. The goal is to leave the company in a position where the remaining founders still have a reason to build it and future investors can see a business they’re willing to back.
That brings us back to ownership and control. Ideally, the departing founder gives up their decision-making rights and retains little, if any, equity. If the team still needs a former founder’s approval, even routine decisions can stall. A large stake held by someone who no longer works in the business can weaken the incentives of those who do and, in some cases, put off future investors.
Plan the handover while the departing founder is still available. Work out who will take over their responsibilities and what they need to do so, from access to GitHub repositories and Google Workspace accounts to introductions to key customers. Check who legally owns the IP the company relies on and resolve any outstanding transfers. You’ll notice quickly if nobody can deploy the software. You may only discover that the company doesn’t own the code when an investor asks for proof.
No founder agreement is in place
Start by establishing the facts. How many shares does the departing founder hold, and what additional shares have they been promised? Do they sit on the board? Do they have an employment agreement? Review any other agreements that give them rights or impose obligations on either side. This tells you what the company can do today and where it still needs the departing founder’s cooperation.
Then find out what each side cares about most. The remaining founders will want to regain control and free up equity for the people who will build the business. The departing founder may care more about being paid for work already done, being released from a non-compete or receive a glowing reference letter. If the two sides value different things, there hopefully is room for a trade.
Sometimes the departing founder refuses to negotiate or cooperate with the handover. They may also insist that the buyback price should reflect the valuation from the last funding round or the valuation cap in the latest SAFE or convertible loan. If that happens, tell them that in this case the company needs to be liquidated and all shares are worth zero. Then, bring the discussion back to what the buyer can realistically pay based on the work performance of the departing founder to date.
Build your opening offer around the cash available today and the incentives the remaining founders need to keep building. Preserve equity for the people who will do that work and avoid committing the proceeds of a future financing round to the buyback. If the founder rejects the cash offer, consider bridging the gap with a small contractual share of the proceeds payable only on a successful exit.
Remember: Both sides have something to lose if the company stalls. The remaining founders need a settlement they can afford and a company they still want to build. The departing founder has an interest in that company surviving, especially if part of their compensation depends on a future exit.
The existing agreement produces an unworkable outcome
Start by establishing the facts, just as you would if there were no agreement. Then work through what the existing terms would mean in practice. If the company cannot live with the result, you’ll need to negotiate a different outcome. The agreement still sets the starting point for that negotiation.
Look closely at any provisions the parties read differently. How is “fair market value” determined? Which activities does the non-compete cover? Understanding where your interpretations differ helps you explain why you’re proposing a different outcome and identify where there’s room to agree.
I’ve advised on cases where the founders negotiated directly, cases where the company brought in its counsel, and cases where each side hired its own lawyer. I’ve seen the widest range of outcomes in that last group. With ambiguous terms and little willingness to compromise, negotiations can drag on for months, cost both sides tens of thousands in legal fees and leave the company unable to move forward. I’ve also seen experienced startup lawyers take some of the emotion out of a dispute and work together to reach a settlement quickly. Much depends on how clear the agreement is and whether the parties and their lawyers can focus on a deal the company can actually carry out.
A workable agreement is in place
This is the best starting point. You’ve reviewed the facts and the relevant documents, and the agreement gives you a departure mechanism the company can put into practice. It’s rare for the terms to give you everything you want. You might think the buyback formula produces too high a price, for example. But if the agreement addresses the points in Part 2, you’re at least working with an outcome you understood and accepted when you signed.
Even then, I’d ask the company’s lawyer to review whether a different arrangement could work better for everyone. An experienced startup lawyer may spot a risk or an opportunity you’ve missed, especially if this is your first founder departure. And the other side may value something you hadn’t considered.
If you find a better solution, get the consent of everyone whose agreement is needed and put the revised terms in writing. If you can’t agree on an improvement, follow the departure mechanism you already have.
Final remark
No matter the circumstances, move as quickly as you can. Where possible, aim to resolve the dispute in days. Some cases inevitably take longer, but do not let negotiations drift. In my experience it is rare that longer settlement negotiations lead to better outcomes and every week that goes by consumes attention, money, and negatively impacts your business trajectory.
Valuable resources
Use these resources to explore the questions, experiences and agreement choices in more depth.
Watch
- Paul Müller (EWOR): Navigating Co-founder Breakups
The Adjust co-founder discusses early team mistakes, honest expectations, responsibility, equity and separation.
- Y Combinator: How Top 1% Founders Navigate Co-founder Conflict
YC partners discuss disagreement, communication styles and the strain of unresolved conflict.
- Y Combinator: Co-Founder Mistakes That Kill Companies
Michael Seibel and Dalton Caldwell discuss common founder mistakes and patterns of unresolved disagreement.
Read and work through
- EWOR: Finding a Co-Founder, the Foundation of Your Venture's Success
Questions and approaches for assessing complementary strengths, shared goals, working styles and expectations.
- EWOR: Co-Founder Equity Splits, Why 50/50 Isn't Always Fair
Use the contribution-weighting exercise to make your assumptions about responsibilities, commitment and risk explicit.
- Paul Graham: The 18 Mistakes That Kill Startups
Read section 17, "Fights Between Founders," for his observations on founder selection, suppressed doubts and departures. (PS: It is also no mistake to read about the other 17 mistakes!)
- Scott Kupor, a16z: Prenups for Co-founders
An investor's perspective on vesting, continued control and planning for departures, written in the context of US venture-backed companies.
- Y Combinator: 10 Questions to Discuss with a Potential Co-founder
A practical questionnaire to answer separately and discuss together, with a checklist covering trial projects, references and regular founder conversations.
If you have any thoughts or additions, reach out to: marco@fehrlegal.com
Related services
This guide provides general information and is not legal or tax advice. It reflects the author's experience. The right terms depend on your company, your founders and your existing documents.
